Grey’s Anatomy Season 21’s Shock Character Return After 17 Years Makes Me Excited For What Else May Happen

Grey’s Anatomy season 20’s finale already set up season 21 to include a Grey Sloan Memorial Hospital more different than ever seen before, but one character’s unexpected return 17 seasons after their last appearance inevitably thrills me. Grey’s Anatomy season 19 including the departure of both Maggie and Meredith from Seattle and a reduced role for Ellen Pompeo as Meredith in the medical drama made me fear the path ahead for the show. Indeed, relying for so many seasons on Meredith, Maggie and Amelia’s sisterhood meant Grey’s Anatomy found itself without two out of three key characters after season 19.

With a reputation for killing off secondary and main characters alike, Grey’s Anatomy ensured some characters could return only in specific ways, for example, when Izzie’s illness showed her Denny, or even when Meredith met Derek, George and Andrew on the beach as she fought off Covid-19. However, many Grey’s Anatomy characters simply disappeared after their arc had reached an end, without them dying or anything being revealed about their fate. That is the case for a character return in Grey’s Anatomy season 21, which took me by surprise because of their previous role and how they hadn't appeared recently.

Dr. Sydney Heron Returning To Grey's Anatomy After 17 Years Is Great News

Sydney’s Bubbly Personality Set Her Apart From Bailey & MAGIC

Sandra Oh as Cristina Yang and Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 7

Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 15

Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron and Katherine Heigl as Izzie Stevens in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 7

Chandra Wilson as Miranda Bailey and Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 15

Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 7

Sandra Oh as Cristina Yang and Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 7

Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 15

Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron and Katherine Heigl as Izzie Stevens in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 7

Chandra Wilson as Miranda Bailey and Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 15

Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 7

Close

Sandra Oh as Cristina Yang and Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 7

Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 15

Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron and Katherine Heigl as Izzie Stevens in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 7

Chandra Wilson as Miranda Bailey and Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 15

Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 7

Sandra Oh as Cristina Yang and Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 7

Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 15

Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron and Katherine Heigl as Izzie Stevens in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 7

Chandra Wilson as Miranda Bailey and Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 15

Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 7

Close

Sandra Oh as Cristina Yang and Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 7

Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 15

Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron and Katherine Heigl as Izzie Stevens in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 7

Chandra Wilson as Miranda Bailey and Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 15

Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 7

Sandra Oh as Cristina Yang and Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 7

Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 15

Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron and Katherine Heigl as Izzie Stevens in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 7

Chandra Wilson as Miranda Bailey and Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 15

Kali Rocha as Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy season 3, episode 7

Close

Dr. Sydney Heron isn’t a character that may easily come to mind thinking back to Grey’s Anatomy’s earliest seasons, and yet her impact on the medical drama was extensive. Having been introduced as the cheery resident to fill in for and in contrast with Miranda Bailey’s approach, Sydney was loathed by some members of MAGIC because of her attitude to “heal with love.” However, Sydney’s character shone through once Cristina pushed Burke to second-guess Sydney in her OR, revealing an assertive resident who knew what she was doing and was right in the end, even succeeding in getting Cristina’s apology.

Kali Rocha returning as Sydney in Grey’s Anatomy season 21 gives the medical drama the chance to update viewers on what she was up to through Grey’s Anatomy’s many disasters of which she was not seen being part. However, what makes her return particularly interesting is how Sydney’s original role was not central, making her return completely unexpected, unlike Arizona’s in Grey’s Anatomy season 20, as she was a beloved, well-known character. Sydney’s conscious cheerfulness created many adversaries for her, including Miranda, making Sydney Heron’s return even more exciting if she were to interact with Miranda Bailey and Richard Webber.

If Sydney Heron Is Back, There's Lots Of Potential For Other Returns In Grey's Anatomy Season 21

Her Return Opens Up Season 21 For Comebacks Of Other Central & Less So Characters

Miranda Bailey And Addison Montgomery Volunteering At The Women's Clinic

Brooke Smith as Dr. Erica Hahn in Grey's Anatomy

Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy

Addison Montgomery is introduced by Jo Wilson and Miranda Bailey to Grey's Anatomy season 19's interns

Split image of Amelia Shepherd and Addison Montgomery

Miranda Bailey And Addison Montgomery Volunteering At The Women's Clinic

Brooke Smith as Dr. Erica Hahn in Grey's Anatomy

Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy

Addison Montgomery is introduced by Jo Wilson and Miranda Bailey to Grey's Anatomy season 19's interns

Split image of Amelia Shepherd and Addison Montgomery

Close

Miranda Bailey And Addison Montgomery Volunteering At The Women's Clinic

Brooke Smith as Dr. Erica Hahn in Grey's Anatomy

Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy

Addison Montgomery is introduced by Jo Wilson and Miranda Bailey to Grey's Anatomy season 19's interns

Split image of Amelia Shepherd and Addison Montgomery

Miranda Bailey And Addison Montgomery Volunteering At The Women's Clinic

Brooke Smith as Dr. Erica Hahn in Grey's Anatomy

Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy

Addison Montgomery is introduced by Jo Wilson and Miranda Bailey to Grey's Anatomy season 19's interns

Split image of Amelia Shepherd and Addison Montgomery

Close

Miranda Bailey And Addison Montgomery Volunteering At The Women's Clinic

Brooke Smith as Dr. Erica Hahn in Grey's Anatomy

Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy

Addison Montgomery is introduced by Jo Wilson and Miranda Bailey to Grey's Anatomy season 19's interns

Split image of Amelia Shepherd and Addison Montgomery

Miranda Bailey And Addison Montgomery Volunteering At The Women's Clinic

Brooke Smith as Dr. Erica Hahn in Grey's Anatomy

Sydney Heron in Grey's Anatomy

Addison Montgomery is introduced by Jo Wilson and Miranda Bailey to Grey's Anatomy season 19's interns

Split image of Amelia Shepherd and Addison Montgomery

Close

Sydney’s last appearance being in Grey’s Anatomy season 4 makes Webber, Meredith and Bailey the only characters Sydney might know, at least based on the relationships the medical drama established. However, Sydney’s return gives her the chance to impact the lives of the new interns, just like she did with MAGIC in Grey’s Anatomy season 2, this time as an attending. This could prompt another set of interns to despise her methods, but I believe it could also be the trial kickstarting future returns for central characters and those less so.

Grey’s Anatomy season 20 seeing Arizona return only so that Bailey could find again the trailblazing surgeries’ magic already hinted at past characters reappearing to support Grey’s Anatomy’s current main characters. However, Sydney appearing in three episodes of Grey’s Anatomy season 21 could also potentially make the medical drama welcome back again characters like Addison Montgomery, or even less central ones like Erica Hahn. Such returns wouldn’t be necessarily highly anticipated, but they can still show the old guard interacting with the new one, thus convincing me they can be just as exciting as any other Grey’s Anatomy character returning.

Grey's Anatomy season 21 premieres on Monday, September 26 at 10 p.m. ET on ABC.

Related Posts

‘Grey’s Anatomy’ Casts a New Yasuda Sibling Before Mika Departs

Mika Yasuda (Midori Francis) might be leaving Grey Sloan, but viewers will learn more about her family before that happens. Deadline reveals that Julia Rose has been…

Grey’s Anatomy’s Jason George Teases There Will Be ‘a Whole New Level of Friction’ Between Bailey and Ben (Exclusive)

Warning: this post contains spoilers from the latest episode of Grey's Anatomy. Jason George is teasing what’s ahead for his Grey's Anatomy character Ben and his wife…

These Real-Life ‘Grey’s Anatomy’ Friendships Will Give You All the Feels—No Surgery Required!

Ellen Pompeo and Patrick Dempsey in 'Grey's Anatomy'moviestillsdb.com/Shondaland After more than 20 years of portraying the same characters, while starring alongside dozens of different actors and participating…

Deceitful Love review: Grey’s Anatomy hunk keeps everyone guessing in lusty age-gap mystery

Forget Patrick Dempsey’s McDreamy. For six years, the most swoonsome doctor in Shonda Rhimes's never-ending hospital drama Grey’s Anatomy was considered to be Giacomo Gianniotti’s Andrew DeLuca. Many viewers…

‘Grey’s Anatomy’ Casts Julia Rose As One Of Mika Yasuda’s Sisters: First-Look Photos

EXCLUSIVE: We will get to know a little more about Mika Yasuda’s (Midori Francis) personal life before she leaves Grey Sloan Memorial Hospital. Julia Rose (Baskets) has…

“Grey’s Anatomy”’s Jason George Teases There Will Be ‘a Whole New Level of Friction’ Between Bailey and Ben (Exclusive)

"They had just started to figure out what their working relationship was when he went out to become a firefighter, but now he's coming in with a…